Beyond Criticism [review of Cleg Kelly Arab of the City]
Dublin Core
Title
Beyond Criticism [review of Cleg Kelly Arab of the City]
Publisher
The Saturday Review of Politics Literature Science and Art
Description
Extended review of Cleg Kelly, Arab of the City (Smith, Elder and Co., 1896) under the heading Beyond Criticism. Discusses the paradox of Crockett's and Ian Maclaren's vast Sunday readership. Argues the reviewer cannot apply ordinary critical standards to Crockett. Includes extended quotations from the novel. Concludes criticism of the book is as useful as criticising a marine store. Mixed-content page: Crockett review occupies most of pp. 40-41.
Date
1896-07-11
Identifier
MAG-121
Language
English
Text Item Type Metadata
Text
Review
Files
Collection
Citation
“Beyond Criticism [review of Cleg Kelly Arab of the City],” S.R.Crockett Museum, accessed October 24, 2026, https://srcrockett.scot/themuseum/items/show/1579.